2012
World Series Winner: Master Ack
World Series Runner-up: L-Train
Regular Season Best Record: Double D’s 4 Me
2013
World Series Winner: Dirty Southpaws
World Series Runner-up: SuperBad
Regular Season Best Record: Double D’s 4 Me
2014
| W | L | GB | |
| Double D’s | 85 | 35 | – |
| L-Train | 69 | 51 | -16 |
| SuperBad | 67 | 53 | -18 |
| Bench Warmers | 58 | 62 | -27 |
| Master | 54 | 66 | -31 |
| El Patrone | 52 | 68 | -33 |
| Dirty SouthPaws | 49 | 71 | -36 |
| Pigz | 46 | 74 | -39 |
World Series Winner: L-Train
World Series Runner-up: Bench Warmers
Regular Season Best Record: Double D’s 4 Me
2015
| W | L | GB | |
| Amazing Mets | 91 | 49 | – |
| Bench Warmers |
84 | 56 | 7 |
| Superbad | 78 | 62 | 13 |
| El Patrone | 74 | 66 | 17 |
| Master Ack | 71 | 69 | 20 |
| Weazels | 68 | 72 | 23 |
| L-Train |
52 | 88 | 39 |
| Killer Cubs |
42 | 98 | 49 |
World Series Winner: Superbad
World Series Runner-up: The Amazing Mets
Regular Season Best Record: Amazing Mets
2016
| W | L | GB | |
| Amazing Mets | 97 | 43 | |
| Superbad |
75 | 65 | – 22 |
| Durdy Southpaws | 74 | 66 | – 23 |
| Weazels | 72 | 68 | – 25 |
| Master Ack | 63 | 77 | – 34 |
| El Patrone | 62 | 78 | – 35 |
| L Train |
60 | 80 | – 37 |
| Bench Warmers |
57 | 83 | – 40 |
World Series Winner: Amazing Mets
World Series Runner-up: Durdy Southpaws
Regular Season Best Record: Amazing Mets
2017
| W | L | GB | |
| The Amazins | 89 | 51 | |
| El Patrone |
80 | 60 | – 9 |
| The Terminator | 73 | 67 | – 16 |
| Bench Warmers | 72 | 68 | – 17 |
| L Train | 71 | 69 | – 18 |
| Wolf Parade | 66 | 74 | – 23 |
| Superbad | 55 | 85 | – 34 |
| Weazels | 54 | 86 | – 35 |
World Series Winner: The Terminator
World Series Runner-up: The Amazins
Regular Season Best Record: The Amazins
2018
| W | L | GB | |
| KKK | 94 | 46 | |
| NWO Wolfpack | 73 | 67 | – 21 |
| Chief Wahoo’s Tribe | 73 | 67 | – 21 |
| Superbad | 68 | 72 | – 26 |
| El Patrone | 68 | 72 | – 26 |
| NWO Hollywood | 67 | 73 | – 27 |
| Bench Warmers | 61 | 79 | – 33 |
| The Terminated | 56 | 84 | – 38 |
World Series Winner: Chief Wahoo’s Tribe
World Series Runner-up: Superbad
Regular Season Best Record: KKK
2019
| W | L | GB | |
| KKK | 97 | 43 | |
| Chief Wahoo’s Tribe | 76 | 64 | – 21 |
| El Patrone | 73 | 67 | – 24 |
| Baby Bombers | 69 | 71 | – 28 |
| Thunderbolts | 66 | 74 | – 31 |
| Superbad | 66 | 74 | – 31 |
| NWO Hollywood | 59 | 81 | – 38 |
| NWO Wolfpack | 54 | 86 | – 43 |
World Series Winner: KKK
World Series Runner-up: Chief Wahoo’s Tribe
Regular Season Best Record: KKK
2020
| W | L | GB | |
| D-Train | 93 | 47 | |
| Gook City | 73 | 67 | – 20 |
| Chief Wahoo’s Tribe | 70 | 70 | – 23 |
| Hitmen | 69 | 71 | – 24 |
| El Patrone | 66 | 74 | – 27 |
| Baby Bombers | 64 | 76 | -29 |
| Black Mambas | 63 | 77 | – 30 |
| Imperium | 62 | 78 | – 31 |
World Series Winner: D-Train
World Series Runner-up: Chief Wahoo’s Tribe
Regular Season Best Record: D-Train
2021
| W | L | GB | |
| El Patrone | 85 | 55 | |
| Gook City | 84 | 56 | -1 |
| Showtime | 78 | 62 | -7 |
| Baby Bombers | 76 | 64 | -9 |
| SouthPaws | 71 | 69 | -14 |
| Imperium | 70 | 70 | -15 |
| Black Mambas | 48 | 92 | -37 |
| Chief Wahoo’s Tribe | 48 | 92 | -37 |
World Series Winner: El Patrone
World Series Runner-up: Showtime
Regular Season Best Record: El Patrone
2022
| W | L | GB | |
| Showtime | 84 | 56 | |
| SouthPaws | 80 | 60 | – 4 |
| Screwballs | 76 | 66 | – 10 |
| Benchwarmers | 74 | 66 | – 10 |
| Chief Wahoo’s Tribe | 72 | 68 | – 12 |
| Moonshots | 63 | 77 | – 21 |
| El Patrone | 58 | 82 | – 26 |
| Black Mambas | 55 | 85 | – 29 |
World Series Winner: SouthPaws
World Series Runner-up: Chief Wahoo’s Tribe
Regular Season Best Record: Showtime
2023
| W | L | GB | |
| Fightin Phils | 111 | 49 | |
| Benchwarmers | 89 | 71 | – 22 |
| El Patrone | 88 | 72 | – 23 |
| SouthPaws | 81 | 79 | – 30 |
| Trump Towers | 74 | 86 | – 37 |
| Chief Wahoo’s Tribe | 70 | 90 | – 42 |
| Screwballs | 67 | 93 | – 44 |
| Black Mambas | 60 | 100 | – 51 |
World Series Winner: Fightin Phils
World Series Runner-up: El Patrone
Regular Season Best Record: Fightin Phils
2024
| W | L | GB | |
| Air Yordan | 102 | 58 | |
| El Patrone | 93 | 67 | – 9 |
| Chief Wahoo’s Tribe | 92 | 68 | – 10 |
| Witt Dreams | 81 | 79 | – 21 |
| Soler Derby | 74 | 81 | – 25 |
| White Reaper | 72 | 88 | – 30 |
| Superbad | 71 | 89 | – 31 |
| Harper’s Roosters | 52 | 108 | – 50 |
World Series Winner: Air Yordan
World Series Runner-up: Chief Wahoo’s Tribe
Regular Season Best Record: Air Yordan