2023 Draft Order:
| Pick | Order | Player | Pick | Order | Player | Pick | Order | Player | Pick | Order | Player |
| rd 1 | Dave | J.Rodriguez | rd 6 | SouthPaws | Greene | rd11 | Ack | Alvarado | rd16 | SouthPaws | – |
| 2 | Vinny | Harris | 42 | SouthPaws | Drury | 82 | Arty | L. Garcia | 122 | Arty | – |
| 3 | Roric | Gimenez | 43 | Dave | Bard | 83 | Roric | Z.Thompson | 123 | Dave | – |
| 4 | Dave | Rutschman | 44 | Screwballs | M. Kelly | 84 | Gregg | C. Walker | 124 | Screwballs | Chapman |
| 5 | Screwballs | Witt, Jr. | 45 | Gregg | J. Adam | 85 | Screwballs | V. Grissom | 125 | Gregg | – |
| 6 | Dave | Strider | 46 | Roric | Ryan | 86 | Vinny | B. Raley | 126 | Roric | – |
| 7 | Vinny | Verlander | 47 | Vinny | Luzardo | 87 | Gregg | McCormick | 127 | Vinny | – |
| 8 | SouthPaws | Kwan | 48 | Gregg | Munoz | 88 | SouthPaws | Casas | 128 | Ack | – |
| rd 2 | SouthPaws | Pena | rd 7 | Arty | O.Gonzalez | rd12 | SouthPaws | – | rd17 | Imperium | – |
| 10 | Ack | Arraez | 50 | SouthPaws | Gorman | 90 | Arty | J. Moran | 130 | Roric | – |
| 11 | Arty | Javier | 51 | Roric | Romano | 91 | Arty | C. Vazquez | 131 | Arty | – |
| 12 | Screwballs | Kirk | 52 | Ack | R. Lopez | 92 | Screwballs | Houck | 132 | Gregg | – |
| 13 | Roric | D. Swanson | 53 | Screwballs | Hoerner | 93 | Gregg | W. Peralta | 133 | SouthPaws | – |
| 14 | Arty | Donovan | 54 | Gregg | Kirby | 94 | Roric | Slater | 134 | Ack | – |
| 15 | Arty | Ward | 55 | Arty | Y. Almonte | 95 | Vinny | R.Contreras | 135 | Dave | – |
| 16 | Gregg | Cortes | 56 | SouthPaws | Stott | 96 | Ack | McCullers | 136 | Vinny | – |
| rd 3 | Arty | Y. Diaz | rd 8 | SouthPaws | M. Perez | rd13 | Ack | Trevino | |||
| 18 | Arty | Stripling | 58 | Arty | Urshela | 98 | Vinny | Moreno | |||
| 19 | Vinny | G.Henderson | 59 | Ack | Pujols | 99 | Roric | Haase | |||
| 20 | SouthPaws | Raleigh | 60 | Screwballs | Story | 100 | Gregg | Santander | |||
| 21 | Screwballs | Mikolas | 61 | Vinny | T.Thompson | 101 | Screwballs | L. Gilbert | |||
| 22 | Gregg | K. Wright | 62 | Roric | Edman | 102 | Dave | D. May | |||
| 23 | SouthPaws | Ty.Anderson | 63 | Ack | Rengifo | 103 | Vinny | Zavala | |||
| 24 | Gregg | Helsley | 64 | Ack | d’Arnaud | 104 | SouthPaws | – | |||
| rd 4 | Dave | Happ | rd 9 | Ack | E. Swanson | rd14 | SouthPaws | – | |||
| 26 | Ack | E. Phillips | 66 | Vinny | H. Greene | 106 | Arty | Springs | |||
| 27 | SouthPaws | Montgomery | 67 | Roric | A. Diaz | 107 | Dave | F. Alvarez | |||
| 28 | Screwballs | Singer | 68 | Vinny | Overton | 108 | Screwballs | Bednar | |||
| 29 | Gregg | O. Cruz | 69 | Dave | Duran | 109 | Gregg | Baty | |||
| 30 | Ack | J. Pederson | 70 | Ack | King | 110 | Roric | Herget | |||
| 31 | Gregg | S. Murphy | 71 | Vinny | Sewald | 111 | Vinny | Guillorme | |||
| 32 | Gregg | Pasquqntino | 72 | SouthPaws | Oviedo | 112 | Ack | Baez | |||
| rd 5 | Roric | McCarthy | rd10 | SouthPaws | Dominguez | rd15 | Ack | M.Carpenter | |||
| 34 | Arty | J. Bell | 74 | Vinny | F. Bautista | 114 | Vinny | CJ Abrams | |||
| 35 | Roric | ParkChange | 75 | Roric | Wesneski | 115 | Roric | Bellinger | |||
| 36 | Gregg | ParkChange | 76 | Ack | H. Kim | 116 | Gregg | – | |||
| 37 | Dave | C. Carroll | 77 | Gregg | Minter | 117 | Screwballs | Hentges | |||
| 38 | Gregg | W.Contrereas | 78 | Roric | H. Ramirez | 118 | Dave | Schreiber | |||
| 39 | Arty | ParkChange | 79 | Arty | Naylor | 119 | Arty | – | |||
| 40 | SouthPaws | MJ Melendez | 80 | Roric | Daza | 120 | SouthPaws | – |